Heart-Shaped Pizza in McHenry County

Looking for a way to make Valentine’s Dinner at home with the family a little more fun and festive? Maybe you have a savory tooth instead of a sweet tooth? Heart-Shaped pizza are here to help you say I love you in the tastiest way possible, with pizza!

heart-shaped pizza

Heart-Shaped Pizza in McHenry County

Restaurants are listed in alphabetical order by city.

Giordano’s Pizza
1505 S. Randall Rd., Algonquin | (847) 854-0076
1388 S. Rt 12, Fox Lake | 847-973-9506
If your heart belongs to Chicago, then you are no stranger to Giordano’s deep dish pizza. On Valentine’s Day, you can get a half-baked or fully-baked pizza to romance your sweetheart without dealing with the crowds. However, be warned that the heart-shaped novelty is smaller than you might be accustomed to ordering.

Nancy’s Pizzeria
1295 N. Randall Rd., Crystal Lake | (815) 459-3333
527 Auburn, Island Lake | (847) 487-4100
The home of stuffed pizza Nancy’s offers both stuffed and thin crust varities in the festive heart shape.

heart-shaped pizza
Photo source Nancy’s on Facebook

Sweet Melissa’s Pizza & Pub
134 Rand Rd., Lakemoor | (815) 575-2100
Any pizza from 11:00 a.m. – 10:00 p.m. on Thursday February 14 at Melissa’s will be heart shaped, same price as the round counter parts just ask for it!

Lou Malnati’s
8515 Redtail Drive, Lakewood | (815) 477-8100
502 Northwest Highway, Cary | (224) 836-9100
Lou Malnati’s is offering their usual Valentine’s Day treat again this year. They have small heart- shaped pizzas at all  locations until February 15th. If your loved one lives far away, but you still think they would love a pizza? Send them one from Lou Malnati’s.

Buddyz A Chicago Pizzeria
1138 N. Green St., McHenry | (815) 363-1010
Heart-shaped pizzas are available by request only. Pre-orders are being accepted now. Dine-in, pick-up and delivery.

Old Town Pizza Company
514 S. IL Route 31, McHenry | (815) 578-1111
If your Valentine is your child, take them to get a heart-shaped pizza! Old Town Pizza Company makes heart-shaped pizza for the kids year round. For Valentine’s Day, they offer the personal 6″ pizzas for only $1.99 in a heart shape. There is no limit to how many you can buy, which makes it perfect for class parties. Orders are due by February 13.

Papa John’s
3804 W. Elm Street, McHenry | (815) 385-7272
248 S. Randall Rd., Algonquin | (815) 960-7272
524 Northwest Highway, Cary | (815) 516-7272
3 US-12, Fox Lake | (847) 587-7272
Known for their delicious garlic butter, this Valentine’s Day you can dip a heart-shaped slice into the butter of your dreams. On Valentine’s Day only, one topping medium pizzas come in the shape of love.

Jimano’s Pizzeria 
366 Bank Dr., McHenry | (815) 385-9555
This neighborhood pizza place offers its communities a little extra love on Valentine’s Day. Order a heart-shaped pizza for the same price of its rounder counterparts, and you’ll be feeling the love. Heart-shaped pizza is available now through Saturday, February 17, just ask for it when orderin

Papa Murphy’s
119 South Eastwood Drive, Woodstock | (815) 337-9900
Unique to Papa Murphy’s is that they offer take-and-bake pizzas. Just pop the pizza in the oven at home and no need to worry about finding a sitter or making dinner reservations.  Papa Murphy’s has their famous “Heartbaker” pizza in a heart shape now through Valentine’s Day.

Did we miss your favorite place? Share the pizza love in the comments!

Show your family you love them this Valentine\'s day with a heart-shaped pizza from one of these McHenry County pizzerias.

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.