Looking for a way to make Valentine’s Dinner at home with the family a little more fun and festive? Maybe you have a savory tooth instead of a sweet tooth? Heart-Shaped pizza are here to help you say I love you in the tastiest way possible, with pizza!
Heart-Shaped Pizza in McHenry County
Restaurants are listed in alphabetical order by city.
1505 S. Randall Rd., Algonquin | (847) 854-0076
1388 S. Rt 12, Fox Lake | 847-973-9506
If your heart belongs to Chicago, then you are no stranger to Giordano’s deep dish pizza. On Valentine’s Day, you can get a half-baked or fully-baked pizza to romance your sweetheart without dealing with the crowds. However, be warned that the heart-shaped novelty is smaller than you might be accustomed to ordering.
1295 N. Randall Rd., Crystal Lake | (815) 459-3333
527 Auburn, Island Lake | (847) 487-4100
The home of stuffed pizza Nancy’s offers both stuffed and thin crust varieties in the festive heart shape.
Sweet Melissa’s Pizza & Pub
134 Rand Rd., Lakemoor | (815) 575-2100
Any pizza from 11:00 a.m. – 10:00 p.m. on Thursday, February 14 at Melissa’s will be heart-shaped, the same price as the round counterparts just ask for it!
8515 Redtail Drive, Lakewood | (815) 477-8100
502 Northwest Highway, Cary | (224) 836-9100
Lou Malnati’s is offering their usual Valentine’s Day treat again this year. They have small heart-shaped pizzas at all locations until February 15th. If your loved one lives far away, but you still think they would love a pizza? Send them one from Lou Malnati’s.
Buddyz A Chicago Pizzeria
1138 N. Green St., McHenry | (815) 363-1010
Heart-shaped pizzas are available by request only. Pre-orders are being accepted now. Dine-in, pick-up, and delivery.
Old Town Pizza Company
514 S. IL Route 31, McHenry | (815) 578-1111
If your Valentine is your child, take them to get a heart-shaped pizza! Old Town Pizza Company makes heart-shaped pizza for the kids year-round. For Valentine’s Day, they offer the personal 6″ pizzas for in a heart shape.
3804 W. Elm Street, McHenry | (815) 385-7272
248 S. Randall Rd., Algonquin | (815) 960-7272
524 Northwest Highway, Cary | (815) 516-7272
3 US-12, Fox Lake | (847) 587-7272
Known for their delicious garlic butter, this Valentine’s Day you can dip a heart-shaped slice into the butter of your dreams. On Valentine’s Day only,
366 Bank Dr., McHenry | (815) 385-9555
This neighborhood pizza place offers its communities a little extra love on Valentine’s Day. Order a heart-shaped pizza for the same price of its rounder counterparts, and you’ll be feeling the love. Heart-shaped pizza is available now through Saturday, February 17, just ask for it when
119 South Eastwood Drive, Woodstock | (815) 337-9900
Unique to Papa Murphy’s is that they offer take-and-bake pizzas. Just pop the pizza in the oven at home and no need to worry about finding a sitter or making dinner reservations. Papa Murphy’s has their famous “Heartbreaker” pizza in a heart shape now through Valentine’s Day.
Did we miss your favorite place? Share the pizza love in the comments!